| # |
Date |
Season |
Game |
Opponent |
H/A |
Score |
Result |
Notes |
| Dec 12, 1891 | 1891-92 | Football Alliance | Bootle | H | 5-1 | Win | |
| Sep 27, 1890 | 1890-91 | Football Alliance | Crewe Alexandra | H | 5-2 | Win | |
| Sep 13, 1890 | | Football Alliance | Darwen | H | 5-2 | Win | |
| Sep 03, 1890 | | Friendly | Notts Olympic | H | 4-0 | Win | |
| Mar 15, 1890 | 1889-90 | Friendly | Chatham | H | 2-0 | Win | |
| Jan 11, 1890 | | Birmingham Cup | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 0-1 | Loss | |
| Nov 30, 1889 | | Friendly | Notts | H | 2-4 | Loss | |
| Nov 16, 1889 | | Friendly | Casuals | H | 3-1 | Win | |
| Oct 24, 1889 | | Friendly | Preston North End | H | 2-1 | Win | |
| Sep 14, 1889 | | Friendly | Halliwell | H | 2-3 | Loss | |
| Apr 06, 1889 | 1888-89 | Friendly | Clapton | H | 3-2 | Win | |
| Mar 30, 1889 | | Testimonial | Notts County | H | 2-5 | Loss | Testimonial for Norman (Forest) and Emmett (Notts) |
| Mar 25, 1889 | | Friendly | Notts Rangers | H | 0-2 | Loss | |
| Mar 09, 1889 | | Friendly | Newton Heath | H | 2-2 | Draw | |
| Mar 04, 1889 | | Friendly | Stoke | H | 1-2 | Loss | |
| 6 | Feb 23, 1889 | | FA Cup | Chatham | H | 2-2 | Draw | |
| 5 | Feb 02, 1889 | | FA Cup | Linfield Athletic | H | 2-2 | Draw | Linfield scratched |
| Jan 19, 1889 | | Friendly | Glasgow Rangers | H | 2-1 | Win | |
| Dec 29, 1888 | | Friendly | Casuals | H | 1-4 | Loss | |
| Dec 22, 1888 | | Friendly | Derby Junction | H | 3-0 | Win | |
| Dec 15, 1888 | | Friendly | Sheffield Heeley | H | 4-1 | Win | |
| Dec 08, 1888 | | Friendly | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 1-2 | Loss | |
| Dec 01, 1888 | | Friendly | Notts County | H | 3-0 | Win | |
| Nov 24, 1888 | | Friendly | Blackburn Olympic | H | 2-3 | Loss | |
| Oct 27, 1888 | | Friendly | Mitchell St. George's | H | 1-0 | Win | |
| Oct 25, 1888 | | Friendly | Preston North End | H | 0-2 | Loss | |
| Oct 20, 1888 | | Friendly | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 1-3 | Loss | |
| Oct 06, 1888 | | Friendly | Long Eaton Rangers | H | 0-2 | Loss | |
| Oct 04, 1888 | | Friendly | Aston Villa | H | 1-2 | Loss | |
| Sep 29, 1888 | | Friendly | Sheffield | H | 8-1 | Win | |
| Sep 22, 1888 | | Friendly | Warwick County | H | 5-0 | Win | |
| Mar 10, 1888 | 1887-88 | Friendly | Aston Unity | H | 4-3 | Win | |
| Feb 18, 1888 | | Friendly | Cambridge University | H | 0-3 | Loss | |
| Feb 14, 1888 | | Friendly | Burnley | H | 1-2 | Loss | |
| Feb 04, 1888 | | Friendly | Lincoln City | H | 2-0 | Win | |
| Jan 21, 1888 | | Friendly | Grimsby Town | H | 2-0 | Win | |
| Dec 27, 1887 | | Friendly | Bolton Wanderers | H | 3-2 | Win | |
| Dec 10, 1887 | | Friendly | Accrington | H | 2-0 | Win | |
| Dec 03, 1887 | | Friendly | Notts | H | 0-1 | Loss | |
| Oct 22, 1887 | | Friendly | Burslem Port Vale | H | 1-1 | Draw | |
| Oct 08, 1887 | | Friendly | Stoke | H | 2-1 | Win | |
| Oct 06, 1887 | | Friendly | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 2-1 | Win | |
| Oct 01, 1887 | | Friendly | Long Eaton Rangers | H | 1-0 | Win | |
| Sep 24, 1887 | | Friendly | Wednesbury Old Athletic | H | 3-2 | Win | |
| Apr 23, 1887 | 1886-87 | Notts Association Cup | Notts Olympic | H | 3-0 | Win | Forest win the Association Cup |
| Apr 16, 1887 | | Notts Association Cup | Notts County | H | 3-1 | Win | |
| Mar 26, 1887 | | Friendly | Wolverhampton Wanderers | H | 0-4 | Loss | |
| Feb 22, 1887 | | Friendly | Burnley | H | 1-1 | Draw | |
| Feb 12, 1887 | | Friendly | Notts County | H | 1-2 | Loss | |
| Jan 22, 1887 | | Friendly | Birmingham Excelsior | H | 6-3 | Win | |
| Dec 28, 1886 | | Friendly | Stoke On Trent | H | 2-0 | | Abandoned due to weather |
| Dec 04, 1886 | | Notts Association Cup | Kimberley Town | H | 7-0 | Win | |
| 4 | Nov 13, 1886 | | FA Cup | Grimsby Town | H | 2-2 | Draw | |
| Nov 06, 1886 | | Friendly | Cambridge University | H | 3-0 | Win | |
| 3 | Oct 30, 1886 | | FA Cup | Notts Olympic | H | 3-0 | Win | |
| Oct 23, 1886 | | Friendly | Accrington | H | 1-4 | Loss | |
| Oct 09, 1886 | | Friendly | Staveley | H | 2-1 | Win | |
| Oct 07, 1886 | | Friendly | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 4-1 | Win | |
| Oct 02, 1886 | | Friendly | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 3-0 | Win | |
| Sep 25, 1886 | | Friendly | Wednesbury Old Athletic | H | 10-0 | Win | |
| Mar 20, 1886 | 1885-86 | Friendly | Sheffield | H | 6-0 | Win | One of two games played on same day |
| Mar 13, 1886 | | Friendly | Small Heath Alliance | H | 1-2 | Loss | One of two games played on same day |
| Feb 27, 1886 | | Friendly | Glasgow Rangers | H | 2-2 | Draw | |
| Feb 06, 1886 | | Friendly | Halliwell | H | 0-2 | Loss | |
| Jan 30, 1886 | | Friendly | Preston North End | H | 1-4 | Loss | |
| Jan 23, 1886 | | Friendly | Bolton Wanderers | H | 0-7 | Loss | |
| Dec 31, 1885 | | Friendly | Casuals | H | 2-0 | Win | |
| Dec 05, 1885 | | Friendly | Derby County | H | 2-1 | Win | |
| Nov 28, 1885 | | Friendly | Notts | H | 1-4 | Loss | |
| 2 | Nov 21, 1885 | | FA Cup | Notts Olympic | H | 4-1 | Win | |
| Nov 14, 1885 | | Friendly | Blackburn Rovers | H | 4-0 | Win | |
| 1 | Oct 31, 1885 | | FA Cup | Mellors | H | 6-2 | Win | |
| Oct 24, 1885 | | Friendly | Aston Villa | H | 0-0 | Draw | |
| Oct 17, 1885 | | Notts Association Cup | Eastwood | H | 4-0 | Win | |
| Oct 10, 1885 | | Friendly | Wednesbury Old Athletic | H | 2-2 | Draw | |
| Oct 03, 1885 | | Friendly | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 3-1 | Win | |
| Sep 26, 1885 | | Friendly | Stoke On Trent | H | 4-1 | Win | |
| Sep 22, 1883 | 1883-84 | Friendly | Small Heath | H | 3-2 | Win | Firest game played at Gregory Ground |
| Oct 26, 1878 | 1878-79 | Friendly | Glasgow Rangers | H | 0-2 | Loss | |
| Dec 12, 1874 | 1874-75 | Friendly | Ambergate Wanderers | H | 0-0 | Draw | The newspaper report only listed 10 players names |
