| # | Date | Game Type | Opponent | H/A | Score | Ground | Scorers | 
|  | Sat Dec 09, 1916 | WWI Initial Tournament | Notts County | A | 2-2 | Meadow Lane | Wightman (?), Tinsley (?) | 
|  | Sat Dec 16, 1916 | WWI Initial Tournament | Rotherham County | H | 2-3 |  | Wightman (?), Tinsley (?) | 
|  | Sat Sep 22, 1917 | WWI Initial Tournament | The Wednesday | H | 3-0 |  | Godfrey (?, ?), Burton (?) | 
|  | Sat Sep 29, 1917 | WWI Initial Tournament | Bradford City | A | 3-0 | Valley Parade | Birch (?), Godfrey (?, ?) | 
|  | Sat Oct 27, 1917 | WWI Initial Tournament | Lincoln City | H | 0-1 |  |  | 
|  | Sat Nov 03, 1917 | WWI Initial Tournament | Lincoln City | A | 1-3 | Sincil Bank | Burton (?) | 
|  | Sat Jan 19, 1918 | WWI Initial Tournament | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-2 | Valley Parade |  | 
|  | Sat Mar 02, 1918 | WWI Initial Tournament | Barnsley | A | 0-1 | Oakwell |  | 
|  | Sat Oct 05, 1918 | WWI Initial Tournament | Lincoln City | H | 1-1 |  | Kirrage (?) | 
|  | Sat May 17, 1919 | WWI Initial Tournament | Everton | A | 1-0 | Goodison Park | ? (?) | 
| 1 | Sat Nov 15, 1919 | League Tier 2 | South Shields | A | 2-5 | Horsley Hill | Davis (30', 55') | 
| 2 | Sat Nov 22, 1919 | League Tier 2 | Tottenham Hotspur | H | 1-1 |  | Davis (71') | 
| 3 | Sat Feb 19, 1921 | League Tier 2 | Leicester City | A | 0-2 | Filbert Street |  | 
| 4 | Sat Feb 26, 1921 | League Tier 2 | Cardiff City | H | 1-2 |  | Harrold (67') |