| # | 
	Date | 
	Game Type | 
	Opponent | 	H/A | 
	Score | 
	Ground | 
	Scorers | 
	
 | Thu Nov 19, 1891 | Football Alliance | Ardwick | H | 4-0 | Town Ground | Higgins (?), Russell (? pen, ?), Smith (?) | 
 | Mon Dec 28, 1891 | Friendly | Derby County | A | 0-3 |  |  | 
| 1 | Sat Jan 30, 1892 | FA Cup | Sunderland Albion | A | 1-0 | Blue House Field | Higgins (?) | 
| 2 | Mon Sep 04, 1893 | League Tier 1 | Everton | A | 0-4 | Goodison Park |  | 
| 3 | Sat Sep 30, 1893 | League Tier 1 | West Bromwich Albion | H | 2-3 | Town Ground | McPherson (?), McInnes (?) | 
| 4 | Mon Jan 01, 1894 | League Tier 1 | Sheffield United | A | 2-0 | Bramall Lane | Pike (?), McPherson (?) | 
 | Fri Apr 26, 1895 | Friendly | Hucknall | A | 5-1 |  | ? (?), McInnes (?, ?, ?, ?) | 
| 5 | Sat Sep 07, 1895 | League Tier 1 | Everton | A | 2-6 | Goodison Park | Carnelly (?), Forman (89') | 
| 6 | Sat Sep 14, 1895 | League Tier 1 | Blackburn Rovers | A | 0-2 | Ewood Park |  | 
| 7 | Sat Nov 23, 1895 | League Tier 1 | Sheffield United | A | 1-2 | Bramall Lane | Smellie (?) | 
 | Tue Apr 26, 1898 | Friendly | Newark | A | 5-0 |  | Richards (?), Forman (?), Iremonger (?, ?), McCracken (?) | 
| 8 | Sat Nov 19, 1898 | League Tier 1 | Preston North End | A | 0-1 | Deepdale |  | 
| 9 | Sat Nov 24, 1900 | League Tier 1 | Notts County | H | 5-0 |  | Norris (9'), Forman (50'), Calvey (65'), Morris (75'), Spouncer (80') | 
| 10 | Thu Jan 02, 1902 | League Tier 1 | Bolton Wanderers | A | 0-3 | Burnden Park |  | 
| 11 | Sat Dec 26, 1903 | League Tier 1 | Middlesbrough | A | 1-1 | Ayresome Park | Morris (35') | 
| 12 | Sat Oct 29, 1904 | League Tier 1 | Derby County | H | 0-1 |  |  | 
| 13 | Sat Mar 18, 1905 | League Tier 1 | Manchester City | H | 2-1 |  | Shearman (?), Lessons (?) | 
| 14 | Sat Mar 25, 1905 | League Tier 1 | Notts County | A | 2-1 | Trent Bridge | Spouncer (?), Morris (?) | 
| 15 | Mon Apr 24, 1905 | League Tier 1 | Everton | H | 0-2 |  |  | 
 | Tue Apr 25, 1905 | Friendly | Leicester Fosse | A | 2-1 |  | Niblo (?, ?) | 
| 16 | Sat Sep 14, 1907 | League Tier 1 | Sheffield United | A | 2-2 | Bramall Lane | Green (?), West (?) |