| Season | Date | Opponent | H/A | Score | Scorers |
|---|
| 1915-16 | Sat Sep 04, 1915 | Grimsby Town | A | 1-1 | Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Sep 11, 1915 | Notts County | H | 3-5 | Wightman (?), Jones (? pen), Birch (?) |
| Sat Sep 18, 1915 | Derby County | A | 4-3 | Jones (? pen, ?), Tinsley (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 02, 1915 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-1 | |
| Sat Oct 09, 1915 | Leeds City | H | 2-0 | Birch (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Oct 16, 1915 | Hull City | A | 3-1 | Martin (?), Bell (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Oct 23, 1915 | Lincoln City | H | 3-2 | Birch (?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 30, 1915 | Barnsley | H | 5-0 | Martin (?), Bell (?), Birch (?), Tinsley (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 06, 1915 | Leicester Fosse | A | 3-1 | Bell (?), Birch (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Nov 13, 1915 | Sheffield United | H | 2-0 | Birch (?), Firth (?) |
| Sat Nov 20, 1915 | Bradford City | A | 0-0 | |
| Sat Nov 27, 1915 | Huddersfield Town | H | 2-0 | Armstrong (?), Birch (?) |
| Sat Dec 04, 1915 | Grimsby Town | H | 2-0 | Wightman (?), Birch (?) |
| Sat Dec 11, 1915 | Notts County | A | 0-0 | |
| Sat Dec 18, 1915 | Derby County | H | 5-0 | Smith (?, ?), Birch (?, ?), Norton (?) |
| Sat Dec 25, 1915 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 1-0 | Norton (?) |
| Mon Dec 27, 1915 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 1-1 | Birch (?) |
| Sat Jan 01, 1916 | Bradford Park Avenue | H | 0-0 | |
| Sat Jan 08, 1916 | Leeds City | A | 0-1 | |
| Sat Jan 15, 1916 | Hull City | H | 4-1 | Bell (?, ?), Birch (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Jan 22, 1916 | Lincoln City | A | 4-1 | Martin (?), Birch (?, ?), Tinsley (? pen) |
| Sat Jan 29, 1916 | Barnsley | A | 1-1 | Wightman (?) |
| Sat Feb 05, 1916 | Leicester Fosse | H | 1-0 | Bell (?) |
| Sat Feb 12, 1916 | Sheffield United | A | 1-3 | Wightman (?) |
| Sat Feb 19, 1916 | Bradford City | A | 0-2 | |
| Tue Apr 25, 1916 | Huddersfield Town | A | 0-2 | |
| 1916-17 | Sat Sep 02, 1916 | Notts County | H | 4-3 | Martin (?), Bell (?), Banks (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Sep 09, 1916 | Rotherham County | A | 1-2 | Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Sep 16, 1916 | Huddersfield Town | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Sep 23, 1916 | Lincoln City | A | 2-1 | Birch (?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 30, 1916 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 5-1 | Bell (?, ?, ?), Birch (?), Banks (?) |
| Sat Oct 07, 1916 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-1 | |
| Sat Oct 14, 1916 | Birmingham City | H | 0-4 | |
| Sat Oct 21, 1916 | Hull City | A | 1-3 | Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Oct 28, 1916 | Chesterfield | A | 3-0 | C Jones (? OG), Birch (?), Godfrey (?) |
| Sat Nov 04, 1916 | Barnsley | H | 3-0 | Birch (?), Tinsley (?, ? pen) |
| Sat Nov 11, 1916 | Leeds City | A | 1-3 | Furbur (?) |
| Sat Nov 18, 1916 | Sheffield United | H | 0-0 | |
| Sat Nov 25, 1916 | Bradford City | A | 2-3 | Godfrey (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 02, 1916 | Leicester Fosse | H | 2-0 | Godfrey (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 09, 1916 | Notts County | A | 2-2 | Wightman (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Dec 16, 1916 | Rotherham County | H | 2-3 | Wightman (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Dec 23, 1916 | Huddersfield Town | A | 2-1 | Godfrey (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Mon Dec 25, 1916 | Grimsby Town | H | 5-1 | Birch (?, ?), Godfrey (?, ?), Banks (?) |
| Tue Dec 26, 1916 | Grimsby Town | A | 1-1 | Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Dec 30, 1916 | Lincoln City | H | 2-0 | Birch (?), Godfrey (?) |
| Sat Jan 06, 1917 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 4-1 | Birch (?), Tinsley (?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Jan 13, 1917 | Bradford Park Avenue | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Jan 20, 1917 | Birmingham City | A | 0-1 | |
| Sat Jan 27, 1917 | Hull City | H | 3-0 | Birch (?, 9'), Tinsley (3') |
| Sat Feb 03, 1917 | Chesterfield | H | 3-0 | Birch (?), Godfrey (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Feb 10, 1917 | Barnsley | A | 1-0 | ? (?) |
| Sat Feb 17, 1917 | Leeds City | H | 3-3 | Godfrey (?, ?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Feb 24, 1917 | Sheffield United | A | 4-1 | Biggin (?), Godfrey (?, ?), Tinsley (? pen) |
| Sat Mar 03, 1917 | Bradford City | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Mar 10, 1917 | Leicester Fosse | A | 1-1 | Godfrey (?) |
| 1917-18 | Sat Sep 01, 1917 | Huddersfield Town | A | 1-2 | Godfrey (?) |
| Sat Sep 08, 1917 | Huddersfield Town | H | 3-0 | Godfrey (?), Burton (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Sep 15, 1917 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 3-0 | Birch (?), Godfrey (?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 22, 1917 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 3-0 | Godfrey (?, ?), Burton (?) |
| Sat Sep 29, 1917 | Bradford City | A | 3-0 | Birch (?), Godfrey (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 06, 1917 | Bradford City | H | 2-0 | Birch (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Oct 13, 1917 | Rotherham County | H | 1-3 | Birch (?) |
| Sat Oct 20, 1917 | Rotherham County | A | 3-1 | Biggin (?), Burton (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Oct 27, 1917 | Lincoln City | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Nov 03, 1917 | Lincoln City | A | 1-3 | Burton (?) |
| Sat Nov 10, 1917 | Grimsby Town | H | 5-0 | Birch (?, ?), Godfrey (?, ?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Nov 17, 1917 | Grimsby Town | A | 1-1 | Burton (?) |
| Sat Nov 24, 1917 | Birmingham City | H | 2-1 | Godfrey (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Dec 01, 1917 | Birmingham City | A | 1-1 | Birch (?) |
| Sat Dec 22, 1917 | Hull City | A | 2-3 | Banks (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Tue Dec 25, 1917 | Notts County | A | 1-0 | Birch (?) |
| Wed Dec 26, 1917 | Notts County | H | 0-0 | |
| Sat Dec 29, 1917 | Hull City | H | 5-1 | Banks (?), Tinsley (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Jan 05, 1918 | Leicester Fosse | A | 0-2 | |
| Sat Jan 12, 1918 | Leicester Fosse | H | 2-0 | Godfrey (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Jan 19, 1918 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-2 | |
| Sat Jan 26, 1918 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-0 | |
| Sat Feb 02, 1918 | Leeds City | A | 0-2 | |
| Sat Feb 09, 1918 | Leeds City | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Feb 16, 1918 | Sheffield United | A | 1-0 | Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Feb 23, 1918 | Sheffield United | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Mar 02, 1918 | Barnsley | A | 0-1 | |
| Sat Mar 09, 1918 | Barnsley | H | 1-0 | Gibson (?) |
| Tue Apr 02, 1918 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-3 | |
| 1918-19 | Sat Sep 07, 1918 | Birmingham City | H | 1-0 | Brown (?) |
| Sat Sep 14, 1918 | Birmingham City | A | 3-2 | Brown (?, ?), Banks (?) |
| Sat Sep 21, 1918 | Rotherham United | H | 3-1 | Brown (?, ?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Sep 28, 1918 | Rotherham United | A | 1-1 | Kirrage (?) |
| Sat Oct 05, 1918 | Lincoln City | H | 1-1 | Kirrage (?) |
| Sat Oct 12, 1918 | Lincoln City | A | 3-1 | Kirrage (?, ?), Lawrence (?) |
| Sat Oct 19, 1918 | Grimsby Town | A | 2-0 | Banks (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Oct 26, 1918 | Grimsby Town | H | 6-1 | Kirrage (?, ?), Bedford (?), Banks (?), Lawrence (?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Nov 02, 1918 | Bradford City | A | 0-1 | |
| Sat Nov 09, 1918 | Bradford City | H | 6-1 | Short (?, ?), Holford (?, ?, ?), Tinsley (?) |
| Sat Nov 16, 1918 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 2-1 | Burton (?), Banks (?) |
| Sat Nov 23, 1918 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 3-1 | Short (?), Banks (?), Holford (?) |
| Sat Nov 30, 1918 | Huddersfield Town | A | 0-0 | |
| Sat Dec 07, 1918 | Huddersfield Town | H | 1-0 | Burton (?) |
| Sat Dec 14, 1918 | Coventry City | H | 0-1 | |
| Sat Dec 21, 1918 | Coventry City | A | 5-2 | Burton (?), Holford (?, ?), Tinsley (?, ?) |
| Wed Dec 25, 1918 | Notts County | H | 2-0 | Shea (?, ?) |
| Thu Dec 26, 1918 | Notts County | A | 1-1 | Banks (?) |
| Sat Dec 28, 1918 | Barnsley | H | 2-0 | Forshaw (?), Birch (?) |
| Sat Jan 11, 1919 | Leicester Fosse | H | 1-1 | Holford (?) |
| Sat Jan 18, 1919 | Leicester Fosse | A | 1-0 | Burton (?) |
| Sat Jan 25, 1919 | Bradford Park Avenue | H | 3-0 | Shea (?, ?), Burton (?) |
| Sat Feb 01, 1919 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 0-2 | |
| Sat Feb 08, 1919 | Leeds City | H | 0-2 | |
| Sat Feb 15, 1919 | Leeds City | A | 4-0 | Birch (?), Burton (?, ?), Holford (?) |
| Sat Feb 22, 1919 | Sheffield United | H | 3-1 | Birch (?, ?), Burton (?) |
| Sat Mar 01, 1919 | Sheffield United | A | 1-1 | Shea (?) |
| Sat Mar 08, 1919 | Hull City | H | 2-1 | Shea (? pen, ?) |
| Sat Mar 15, 1919 | Hull City | A | 0-5 | |
| Tue Apr 22, 1919 | Barnsley | A | 2-3 | Shea (?, ?) |
| Sat May 10, 1919 | Everton | H | 0-0 | |
| Sat May 17, 1919 | Everton | A | 1-0 | ? (?) |
